The two pictures where taken at the exact same scale for a fashion magazine. Although the ears and nose from the model on the right are larger, Aurelies's jaw (on the left) is much larger.
I can definitely see the superior beauty here in the square jawed woman also the fact that her nose is narrower and well chiseled makes her an appropriate candidate for a square jaw. Not all women, in my opinion, would look good with a square jaw. It can one way or another for some people.